City of St. Louis v. State

The City of St. Louis appealed the trial court's holding that the prohibition against special laws contained in Mo. Const. art. III, 40 was not violated by Mo. Rev. Stat. 320.097. That statute exempted certain veteran firefighters who lived in areas with unaccredited or provisionally accredited school districts from any local laws requiring them to live in their home district. The State also appealed, alleging (1) the trial court erred in holding that section 320.097 violated what the trial court believed was the "broad measure of complete freedom from State legislative control" given to constitutional charter cities by the Missouri Constitution, and (2) the trial court erred in holding that the statute violated the equal protection clauses of the Missouri and U.S. constitutions because it was not rationally related to any legitimate purpose. The Supreme Court (1) affirmed the trial court's holding that the statue was not a special law in violation of the Missouri Constitution; (2) reversed the trial court's holding that the statute violated the state constitution because it interfered with the City's right to set its employees' and officers' powers, duties and compensation; and (3) reversed the trial court's holding that the statute violated equal protection guarantees. View "City of St. Louis v. State" on Justia Law